A modest proposal

12 April 2011

Free speech can sometimes be a hard thing to stand up for (witness the Terry Jones and Fred Phelps groups), and likewise the concept of Freedom of Information. In Wisconsin, state Republicans are using the latter to get access to all the email of a prominent University of Wisconsin professor, William Cronon (who has criticized efforts to strip state workers of the right to join unions), looking for times when he crossed the line from state employee to political advocate using his university email account. In Michigan, Republicans have submitted FOIA requests for vast swaths of faculty email from targeted departments at Wayne State, the U. of Michigan, and Michigan State. There, they’ve narrowed their search down by looking only for certain keywords, including:

  • Scott Walker
  • Madison
  • Wisconsin
  • Rachel Maddow (?!?)

So here’s my proposal: I suggest all of us put the term Scott Walker into every single one of our university emails. Every time we schedule a meeting by email, stick “Scott Walker” in the middle, no matter how nonsensical. Every time we grant a student an extension by email, Scott Walker. Every time we fill out a form and submit it via email to some university office, Scott Walker. I suggest we request of our students that if they’re going to send an effusive email to us thanking us for the 15 letters of recommendation we wrote on their behalf, they ought to mention Scott Walker.

I don’t doubt that these FOIA requests amount to an attempt to embarrass Bill Cronon in Wisconsin and faculty in Michigan. I also don’t doubt that this is acceptable and legal under the idea of Freedom of Information, which is intended as a value-neutral attempt to make government more transparent. I just think that if people try to embarrass university faculty — truly one of the least radical and most fearful groups of individuals in the US today — those activists ought to have to wade through an awful lot of the quotidian work we do every single day on behalf of universities and students. This work is burdensome, generous, and utterly apolitical. If activists seek to humiliate faculty, they ought to have to see our labor in its entirety.

Advertisements

4 Responses to “A modest proposal”


  1. Love your idea. But, as a public school teacher in one of the most conservative areas of the state, I would probably be fired just for having his name in one of my emails (unless I was praising his name, of course). So, add a few “scott walkers” to your messages for me.

    • Didion Says:

      Oh, I find this so depressing. So much for the freedom of speech.

      It makes me think that speaking aloud the name “Scott Walker” is a bit like speaking the name “Voldemort.” Let’s turn to calling him He Who Must Not Be Named instead.

  2. servetus Says:

    What I like about this is that it operationalizes an idea I’ve had for awhile: that the average legislator could not keep up with what the average professor is required to do during a day. My fear is that only attorneys would read these emails.

    xoxo from your favorite cheesehead-born professor.

  3. Hattie Says:

    Academics and teachers are totally cowed, which is what makes them such good targets. I think your suggestion is good. In fact, though not an academic, I’m going to pass your suggestion on. I think I will even spread his name around on Facebook and Twitter.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: